Advice » In the Workplace» Workplace Issues » Personal Beliefs Can Pit Health ...
Personal Beliefs Can Pit Healthcare Workers Against Patients and Colleagues

Personal Beliefs Can Pit Healthcare Workers Against Patients and Colleagues

An EMT instructed to transport a woman to an abortion clinic declines, citing personal beliefs. A nurse ordered to administer a large dose of morphine to a terminal cancer patient in pain refuses, saying the medication could hasten death. A physician turns away a gay patient, apparently on the basis of his sexual orientation.

Are these scenarios examples of healthcare workers asserting their right of individual conscience, or are they unethical, perhaps illicit denials of patients' rights to receive medically appropriate treatments?

This question is at the center of a simmering debate that is moving beyond pharmacists who refuse to dispense contraceptives to other hot-button issues, such as in vitro fertilization, physician-assisted suicide and stem-cell research, affecting a wide variety of specialties in healthcare. Although there's no reliable statistical evidence that more US healthcare workers are refusing to treat on moral grounds, anecdotal evidence indicates the phenomenon is growing. A variety of bills and laws, mainly on the state level, either grant or deny healthcare workers the right to refuse treatment.

Healthcare Workers' Conscience vs. Patients' Rights

The disagreement is deeply entrenched.

"This is a conflict of the constitutionally based right of conscience and the patient's right of convenience," says Dr. David Stevens, executive director of the Christian Medical & Dental Associations.

Others say healthcare workers who refuse to provide treatment are breaching their professional duty to put the patient first.

Present and future healthcare workers need to know that these legal, ethical and ideological battles threaten to alter professional relationships and change career arcs.

Employer-Employee Communication Makes a Difference

Partisans on both sides say it's important for healthcare workers to inform their employers about what procedures they won't perform -- before they are asked to perform them. Some jurisdictions require such notification.

"A California law requires that pharmacists reveal to their employers which treatments they won't provide," says Judy Waxman, vice president for health and reproductive rights at the National Women's Law Center.

Conversely, healthcare employers have a duty to inform job candidates if they won't tolerate treatment refusals. "Companies need to lay out the terms of the job and the expectations when workers are hired," says Arthur Caplan, director of the University of Pennsylvania Center for Bioethics.

Some assert that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 forces employers to share the burden of reconciling workers' beliefs with patients' rights. "When an employee makes a request based on religious belief, the employer must attempt a reasonable accommodation but need not take on an undue hardship," says Francis Manion, senior counsel for the American Center for Law & Justice, which represents healthcare workers who have refused to treat.

Still, workers who decline to provide treatment run the risk of alienating peers. "Coworkers will think you're nuts or evil, but that's just how life is," says Kevin McDonnell, a philosophy professor at all-female Saint Mary's College, which is affiliated with the Roman Catholic Church, and a specialist in medical ethics.

Personal Beliefs May Impact Career Choices

Those considering a healthcare career or job change should reflect on how their beliefs align with potential job duties. "Some medical students are required to do abortions, and most of our premed students won't do them, so they're going to have a big fight," McDonnell says.

On the other hand, healthcare workers who believe they must provide any medically appropriate treatment may find themselves curtailed in some settings.

"If you go and work in a Catholic hospital, you are under Catholic healthcare directives, (and) you're ruled by what the bishops and the pope say," Waxman says. "Healthcare workers need to know how their activities may be limited by these directives."

Treatment of Gays and Lesbians Is Also a Battleground

Some healthcare providers deny or limit the care they provide gays and lesbians. "I may not approve of homosexuality, but that doesn't mean I don't treat them," Stevens says. "But I don't help homosexuals conceive children."

Says Jennifer Pizer, senior counsel for Lambda Legal, which advocates for the rights of gays and lesbians: "There's a great obligation on the part of a religious believer to find an occupation where their practice won't injure third parties," such as lesbian patients seeking artificial insemination. "Having a religious motive for the conduct doesn't take away the harm."

Learn more about healthcare careers.

Latest Jobs

Posted: 07/01/2015
Denver, CO, 80216
Michael Page USA
Posted: 07/01/2015
California, CA
Posted: 07/01/2015
SHERMAN, TX, 75090
Parker and Lynch
Posted: 07/01/2015
Los Angeles, CA, 90071
Posted: 07/01/2015
Houston, TX, 77029

Want more personalized results?  Update Your Profile


Monster Communities

Teaching Community
Where teachers meet and learn.
Create and connect.
Networking for the career-minded woman.
Nursing Link
Where nurses call the shots.
More Monster Communities

Monster Partners

Scholarships, financial aid and more ways to pay for school.
Find top campus and online degree programs.
Military portal for the US Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps and Coast Guard.
Financial Aid
Scholarships & financial aid.
Staffing for Government Jobs
Staffing and hiring solutions for federal government agency jobs.
More Monster Partners

Job Hunt Strategy

Six Ways to Make a Recruiter Hate You
If you want to blow your chances with recruiters -- and, by extension, with the companies they work for -- here are six perfect ways to do so.

Resumes & Cover Letters

Rev Up Your Resume to Relocate
Hoping to relocate? Get the ball rolling on landing the right job in the right location with these expert resume and cover letter tips.


100 Potential Interview Questions
Interview questions can run the gamut. You probably won't face all 100 of these, but you should still be prepared to answer at least some of them.

Salary & Benefits

10 Questions to Ask When Negotiating Salary
Most of us aren't natural negotiators, but asking these 10 questions during salary negotiations can help you get everything you deserve.

Employee Sourcing

Alt text
November Monster Employment Index Grows 13% Year-Over-Year, Tenth Consecutive Month of Positive Annual Growth.

For Seekers

Campus and Online Degrees
Advance your career and earn more with an online degree.
Free Salary Wizard
What are you worth? Find out and negotiate a better salary.
Research Careers
Get information on jobs and career paths to help guide your choices
Questions & Answers
Find answers to all your career related questions -- powered by Yahoo! Answers
Resume Distribution Service
Our distribution service puts your resume right in the hands of recruiters.
Resume Writing Services
Our experts will craft a keyword-rich resume that stands out in the crowd.
More Career Resources

For Employers

Career Ad Network
Target your job posting to more candidates on thousands of websites.
Hire Right Background Checks
Explore our background check packages to improve the quality of your hires.
Hiring Home Page
Find the best candidates for your business with Monster hiring solutions.
Job Postings
Find the right solution for your hiring needs. Starting at $99.
Power Resume Search
Monster's new search technology precisely matches people with your jobs.
Resource Center
Find staffing insights, labor trends, HR best practices and more.
Target Post
Connect with skilled, hourly and administrative candidates for only $99.

Social Media

Jobs on Twitter
Find jobs in your area and industry.
Monster Careers
Tune into our career advice and discussions tackling a wide range of topics and industries.
Monster Corporate & PR
Stay up-to-date on the latest news. Get the 'Who', 'What', 'When', and 'Why' on all things Monster related.
Monster Customer Service
Got a Monster question? We've got the answer. Whether you're a job seeker or employer, we can help you find the answers you need.
Monster for Employers
Find advice on hiring.
Follow Us
Check out our many pages and stay connected with the latest industry news, events, career advice and job openings.

Other Links

Monster Company Profiles
Explore companies and get information to guide your career decisions.
Compare Salaries
See how your pay stacks up to others in your field.
iPhone Application
Download the Monster app for iPhone and iPod touch.
Monster Job Seeker Blog
Monster Job Seeker Blog.
Monster Thinking Blog
Monster's Recruitment Trends Blog.
Jobs & Career Resources
Search Jobs:
For Employers: Post Jobs | Search Resumes | Advertise
About Monster | Work for Monster | Advertise with Us | AdChoices | Partner with Us | Investor Relations | Social Media
Terms of Use | Privacy Center | Accessibility Center | Help | Security | Contact Us | Sitemap | Mobile
©2015 Monster - All Rights Reserved U.S. Patents No. 5,832,497; 7,599,930 B1; 7,827,125 and 7,836,060 MWW - Looking for Monster Cable? - V: 2015.12.0.54-204